JEQ Journal of Natural Resources and Life Sciences Education
HOME HELP FEEDBACK SUBSCRIPTIONS ARCHIVE SEARCH TABLE OF CONTENTS
 QUICK SEARCH:   [advanced]


     


Published online 1 March 2006
Published in J Environ Qual 35:590-598 (2006)
DOI: 10.2134/jeq2005.0127
© 2006 American Society of Agronomy, Crop Science Society of America, and Soil Science Society of America
677 S. Segoe Rd., Madison, WI 53711 USA
This Article
Right arrow Abstract Freely available
Right arrow Figures Only
Right arrow Full Text (PDF) Free
Right arrow Alert me when this article is cited
Right arrow Alert me if a correction is posted
Services
Right arrow Similar articles in this journal
Right arrow Similar articles in ISI Web of Science
Right arrow Similar articles in PubMed
Right arrow Alert me to new issues of the journal
Right arrow Download to citation manager
Citing Articles
Right arrow Citing Articles via HighWire
Right arrow Citing Articles via ISI Web of Science (3)
Right arrow Citing Articles via Google Scholar
Google Scholar
Right arrow Articles by Henry, A.
Right arrow Articles by Bugbee, B.
Right arrow Search for Related Content
PubMed
Right arrow PubMed Citation
Right arrow Articles by Henry, A.
Right arrow Articles by Bugbee, B.
Agricola
Right arrow Articles by Henry, A.
Right arrow Articles by Bugbee, B.
Related Collections
Right arrow Laboratory Column Studies
Right arrow Lysimeter/Rhizosphere Studies
Right arrow Bioremediation and Biodegradation
Right arrow Experiment Design
Right arrow Plant Nutrition

TECHNICAL REPORTS

Plant and Environment Interactions

An Axenic Plant Culture System for Optimal Growth in Long-Term Studies

Amelia Henrya, William Doucetteb, Jeanette Nortona, Scott Jonesa, Julie Charda and Bruce Bugbeea,*

a Department of Plants, Soils, and Biometeorology, Utah State University, Logan, UT 84322
b Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, Utah State University, Logan, UT 84322

* Corresponding author (bruce.bugbee{at}usu.edu)

Received for publication April 15, 2005.

    ABSTRACT
 TOP
 NOTES
 ABSTRACT
 INTRODUCTION
 MATERIALS AND METHODS
 RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
 CONCLUSIONS
 REFERENCES
 
The symbiotic co-evolution of plants and microbes leads to difficulties in understanding which of the two components is responsible for a given environmental response. Plant–microbe studies greatly benefit from the ability to grow plants in axenic (sterile) culture. Several studies have used axenic plant culture systems, but experimental procedures are often poorly documented, the plant growth environment is not optimal, and axenic conditions are not rigorously verified. We developed a unique axenic system using inert components that promotes plant health and can be kept sterile for at least 70 d. Crested wheatgrass (Agropyron cristatum cv. CDII) plants were grown in sand within flow-through glass columns that were positively pressured with filtered air. Plant health was optimized by regulating temperature, light level, CO2 concentration, humidity, and nutrients. The design incorporates several novel aspects, such as pretreatment of the sand with Fe, graduated sand layers to optimize the air–water balance of the root zone, and modification of a laminar flow hood to serve as a plant growth chamber. Adaptations of several sterile techniques were necessary for maintenance of axenic conditions. Axenic conditions were verified by plating and staining leachates as well as a rhizoplane stain. This system was designed to study nutrient and water stress effects on root exudates, but is useful for assessing a broad range of plant–microbe–environment interactions. Based on total organic C analysis, 74% of exudates was recovered in the leachate, 6% was recovered in the bulk sand, and 17% was recovered in the rhizosphere sand. Carbon in the leachate after 70 d reached 255 µg d–1. Fumaric, malic, malonic, oxalic, and succinic acids were measured as components of the root exudates.

Abbreviations: GC-MS, gas chromatography–mass spectrometry • LC-MS, liquid chromatography–mass spectrometry • TOC, total organic carbon


    INTRODUCTION
 TOP
 NOTES
 ABSTRACT
 INTRODUCTION
 MATERIALS AND METHODS
 RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
 CONCLUSIONS
 REFERENCES
 
ARTIFACTS from axenic culture must be minimized to obtain reliable measurements of plant responses in the absence of microbial organisms. The term "axenic" refers to a system in which all biological populations are defined. Axenic plant culture is the growth of plants in the absence of microbes. Other terms used to describe these types of systems include sterile, aseptic, and gnotobiotic. Few axenic plant culture systems have optimized the environment for plant growth and most systems have been designed only for short-term studies. The main challenge associated with long-term axenic plant culture is to maintain optimal plant growth conditions in a microbe-free environment. This is imperative to study the effects of various treatments and assure that responses are due to those treatments alone, not artifacts from suboptimal growth conditions.

An ideal axenic plant culture system should provide: (i) continuous control of CO2, temperature, humidity, and light in the shoot zone; (ii) adequate nutrients, water, and O2 and absence of light in the root zone; (iii) appropriate mechanical impedance to root elongation; (iv) inert materials; (v) maintenance of sterility; (vi) rigorous tests to verify sterility; (vii) capability to apply treatments such as nutrient stress or inoculation; and (viii) access to collect root-zone leachate.

Although it is necessary to avoid unintentional stresses in axenic studies, not all in vitro plant culture systems promote plant health. Agar plates (Heist et al., 2002) or agar with Millipore (Billerica, MA) membranes (Meharg and Killham, 1991) have been used as simple axenic plant culture setups, but do not supply adequate airflow or allow uniform nutrient, water, or O2 delivery to the root surfaces. Agar media allow continuous monitoring of sterility but do not facilitate long-term studies. It is also difficult to extrapolate results from agar plates to the field.

Axenic liquid hydroponic cultures have been widely used (e.g., Mench and Martin, 1991; Groleau-Renaud et al., 1998), particularly for short-term (<1 wk) studies. However, root morphology and growth are significantly altered in hydroponics, compared with the field, due to reduced mechanical impedance and absence of root hairs. The viability of microbes that might be inoculated into a hydroponic system is limited by the lack of surfaces to colonize.

Soil provides a growth medium more like field conditions and has been used for axenic plant culture (Whipps and Lynch, 1983). However, soil is difficult to sterilize and structural and geochemical changes occur from autoclaving or {gamma} irradiation.

Porous solid substrates also provide growth conditions similar to the field but are more easily sterilized. Biondini et al. (1988) enclosed plant roots in pots of sterilized fritted clay with ports for solution input and output. Sand has also been used as a growth medium for axenic plant culture (Ayers and Thornton, 1968; Lipton et al., 1987; Hodge et al., 1996). Sand has fewer reactive surfaces than soil or fritted clay. Certain types of commercially available sand are more inert than others due to increased purity of silica in their composition, which decreases reactivity. Glass beads are considerably more expensive than sand and may affect nutrient solution composition (Sandnes and Eldhuset, 2003).

Sterilization methods most commonly used include autoclaving of the system components, {gamma} irradiation or autoclaving of the growth medium, and surface sterilization of seeds by soaking in dilute solutions of H2O2, NaOCl, or HgCl2.

Most previous studies have used a preliminary test for contamination by germinating surface-sterilized seeds on agar plates. Many studies also performed a secondary test for contamination using a plate count of solution at the end of the study (Mench and Martin, 1991; Basu et al., 1994; Groleau-Renaud et al., 1998). Other studies did not indicate how axenic conditions were verified after planting (Barber and Lynch 1977; Hodge et al., 1996). Since <1% of all soil microbes are capable of growing on agar plates, additional tests such as light or fluorescence microscopy are required because contamination by certain species may go undetected (Brock, 1987).

There are few long-term (i.e., >40 d) axenic plant studies because it is difficult to keep the systems free of microbes. Lipton et al. (1987) grew alfalfa for 24 d under sterile conditions in a completely enclosed system with a tube containing sand for the root-zone container and an inverted beaker as the shoot-zone container, but the setup did not provide airflow around the shoots. Hodge et al. (1996) developed an enclosed system that allowed inoculation of microorganisms and used radio-labeled CO2 to track the flow of assimilated carbon. Four ports were drilled into the growth container that allowed air and fluid exchange to and from the system during a 34-d growth period. Paterson and Sim (1999, 2000) modified these systems to reduce carbon contamination by the system components and to reinforce seals. Our goal was to develop a plant culture system in which axenic conditions could be maintained while facilitating optimal plant growth for several months to study root exudates. We sought to design a simple system with inert components that would be less prone to contamination with time, identify unique sterile techniques for axenic plant culture, use adequate methods to verify the absence of microbes, and include measures to promote plant health.


    MATERIALS AND METHODS
 TOP
 NOTES
 ABSTRACT
 INTRODUCTION
 MATERIALS AND METHODS
 RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
 CONCLUSIONS
 REFERENCES
 
Plant Growth Container: Root Zone
The root-zone container was a 220-mm-long glass column (38-mm outside diameter, 35-mm inside diameter) with two ports at the top: one for addition of nutrient solution and one for air (Fig. 1). Five layers of Ottawa sand (99.9% pure quartz sand, U.S. Silica Co., Berkeley Springs, WV) with different grain sizes were used as the growth medium. The depth of each layer was calculated according to the approximated water retention curves plotted in Fig. 2 using the van Genuchten (1980) model and parameters for {alpha} and n that describe different sand grades from Schroth et al. (1996). Each layer's lower boundary corresponds with the intersection of the 90% saturation level or maximum water content of the respective retention curve. The shape of the retention curve determines the lower water content level found at the interface with the adjacent layer above. The more coarse-grained sand formed the bottom layer and increasingly finer grain (and pore) sizes formed the layers above. Intermediate water retention properties were obtained by a 50:50 mix using two adjacent sand sizes together, the water retention curves of which were assumed to be represented by the average of the neighboring layer parameters.


Figure 1
View larger version (30K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
 
Fig. 1. Glass column system used for axenic plant culture and study of root exudates.

 

Figure 2
View larger version (26K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
 
Fig. 2. Relationship between volumetric water content and matric potential in each of the five sand layers of the column as predicted by the van Genuchten (1980) water retention model: (A) water retention curves for the sand sizes used, and (B) thickness of each layer. The quasi-static equilibrium after drainage provides a volumetric water content between 0.15 and 0.32 in each layer.

 
The layer thicknesses (and grain sizes) were, from top to bottom: 45-mm fine (0.315–0.425 mm); 35-mm fine–medium mix (0.315–0.630 mm); 25-mm medium (0.425–0.630 mm); 25-mm medium–coarse mix (0.425–0.850 mm); 30-mm coarse (0.630–0.850 mm). See Table 1 for size conversions. Sand volume in the column was 154 cm3. The column was closed on the bottom with a one-holed silicone stopper with a 95-mm-long glass drain tube lined with a silanized glass wool wick to draw water flow from the coarse sand (bottom) layer. (Silanization is the chemical conversion of hydroxyl groups with silane coupling agents to inactivate adsorption sites on silica or glass. Silanization neutralizes surface charges, thus eliminating nonspecific binding.) The glass wool wick and surrounding tube were attached to a leachate collection vial with a two-holed silicone stopper (one hole filled with glass wool to allow air displacement while preventing contamination). The 95-mm-long drain tube and wick provides 95 mm of suction at the bottom boundary of the sand shortly after drainage, which maintains the appropriate moisture content in the sand.


View this table:
[in this window]
[in a new window]
 
Table 1. Conversion for grit or sieve size to particle diameter.

 
The sand in the columns was preloaded with FeCl3 to increase plant Fe availability since all commonly used Fe chelates (e.g., Fe-EDTA) contain C and interfere with TOC (total organic carbon) analysis. Before autoclaving, about 0.3 L of 200-µM FeCl3 (pH = 2) was poured through the columns until the pH of the solution leaching from the sand decreased to <4. About 0.3 L of nutrient solution (pH = 5.5) was then poured through the sand to increase the pH within the column and precipitate the Fe on the surface of the sand. In preliminary studies, plants without this Fe treatment were sometimes chlorotic.

Water Availability
Transpiration tests were conducted to determine the readily available volume of water in the columns. Transpiration rates of mature crested wheatgrass grown under nonaxenic conditions were measured for up to 40 h. Water use was determined gravimetrically. The volume of plant-available water was estimated based on the water content at which transpiration rates began to decline.

Sorption to Ottawa Sand
Sorption tests were performed using unplanted sand columns with the Fe-loading treatment. Twenty milliliters of 0.02 M KCl and 0.02 M oxalic and malic acids (pH raised to 8) plus 20 mL of deionized water were added to three unplanted sand columns, followed by five rinses of 40 mL of deionized water. The recovery of the solutions was monitored using an electrical conductivity meter to determine the difference between the electrical conductivity of the solution added to the columns and leachate collected. Amounts of organic acids used for the sorption test represented cumulative amounts of C exuded by plants during the 70-d study.

Plant Growth Container: Shoot Zone
The top section of the container was made from a second 220-mm-long glass column connected to the root-zone column by a ground glass joint. The column was sealed at the top with an open-cell foam plug to prevent microbial contamination (Fig. 1).

Plant Culture
One pregerminated crested wheatgrass seed (cv. CDII, Asay et al., 1997) was planted in each root-zone column, except the unplanted column. All columns were maintained for 70 d in a laminar flow hood. The hood was modified for plant growth by installing two high-pressure sodium lamps, which supplied a PPF (photosynthetic photon flux) of 550 µmol m–2 s–1 during a 16-h photoperiod (Fig. 3). The air temperature was maintained at 25°C. Plants were watered to excess with filtered and autoclaved nutrient solution (pH = 5.5) to obtain at least 0.025 L of leachate and maintain healthy plants. The frequency of watering increased from once every 3 to 4 d at the beginning of the study to once every 2 d at the end of the study. The composition of the nutrient solution was predetermined under nonaxenic conditions for optimal growth (Table 2). Nutrient solution concentrations were reduced to half-strength after Day 35 to minimize potential salt buildup in the root zone. Filtered airflow through the shoot-zone columns was supplied during the light period. Airflow was maintained at 0.065 L min–1 after emergence and was gradually adjusted to 1.0 L min–1 at harvest to prevent condensation inside the shoot-zone columns. Airflow manifolds were mounted directly to the racks holding the columns, which improved laminar flow of sterile air through the workspace (Fig. 3).


Figure 3
View larger version (167K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
 
Fig. 3. Plants grown in a laminar flow hood with a photosynthetic photon flux of 550 µmol m–2 s–1 from high-pressure sodium lamps. Plant growth columns were supported by racks that allowed air flow between and around the columns.

 

View this table:
[in this window]
[in a new window]
 
Table 2. Nutrient solution composition.

 
Columns were supported in racks made of Plexiglas and angled aluminum edging, which could be surface sterilized with 70% ethanol. These racks reduced possible contamination because they could easily be cleaned and they allowed laminar flow of sterile air between the columns. Root zones were protected from light by wrapping columns with aluminum foil.

Collection of Leachate
Amber vials containing nutrient solution leachate and root exudates were replaced with sterilized, empty vials after each watering. Leachate samples were capped and stored at 4°C until analysis within 24 h.

Procedures to Minimize Adsorption and Desorption of Carbon
Adsorption and desorption of carbon by system components would significantly interfere with analysis of root exudates. Selection of inert components and treatments of the components were necessary to assure that the plants were the only source of C in the leachate samples, and that minimal amounts of plant-derived material adsorbed to system components.

Organic C was removed from the sand to minimize background C levels. Heating in a muffle furnace at 600°C was effective in removing C from small volumes of sand (<25 g) but was impractical for the large volumes of sand required for this study since the heat could not penetrate the entire volume of sand to effectively volatilize organic C. Sand was instead treated according to Guy (1969). Sand was washed with deionized water, dried at 90°C, washed with 30% H2O2 (v/v), and dried overnight at 90°C while stirring several times to increase the reaction of organic C with H2O2. The H2O2 treatment was repeated and the sand was given a final rinse with filtered (0.45-µm) deionized water. The sand was then poured into the glass columns and autoclaved twice, 1 d apart, for 1 h at 145 kPa and 121°C to allow any remaining endospores to germinate between autoclavings.

Silicone stoppers were used instead of rubber stoppers. All glass and silicone components of the system were rinsed with methanol, dried at 80°C to remove trace organic C, and autoclaved for 45 min at 145 kPa and 121°C.

Procedures to Minimize Microbial Contamination
Improved methods to facilitate long-term axenic plant culture were used, particularly techniques that maintained sterility while allowing optimal growth.

To achieve a high percentage of microbe-free seed, it was necessary to agitate crested wheatgrass seeds on a shaker for 60 min in a solution with 20% Clorox (Clorox Co., Oakland, CA) and 0.1% Tween 80 as a wetting agent (VWR International, Chicago, IL). Seeds were rinsed with sterilized, deionized water and placed on petri plates with 1/10 strength Difco nutrient broth (Becton, Dickinson and Co., Franklin Lakes, NJ) and Bacto agar (1.5%, Becton, Dickinson and Co.) in a 25°C incubator for 3 d to test for residual microbial activity on the seed surface. After 3 d, the radicles were ~15 mm long. On average, one seed out of 50 had residual contamination. Seed vigor compared with untreated controls was not significantly reduced. Germination rate was 72% after 6 d.

Plant-growth containers were assembled and seedlings were transplanted from the petri dishes to the root-zone columns in a laminar flow hood. Forceps and column lips were flamed before use. All manipulations were done using sterile gloves.

Air was pumped through the upper part of the glass plant-growth columns to supply CO2 and remove H2O vapor. This air was filtered through glass wool and foam plugs before and after the pump, and through a sterilized, bacterial air filter (aerosol retention = 0.3 µm, Pall Gelman Sciences Corp., Ann Arbor, MI) before entering each column.

Nutrient solution was filtered through a 0.45-µm membrane, then autoclaved at 145 kPa and 121°C for at least 45 min. After autoclaving, the nutrient solution was allowed to cool completely before using it to water the plants. Separate flasks of nutrient solution and sterile syringes were used to water each group of plants. Septa were cleaned with 70% ethanol and allowed to dry before each injection. A new sterile needle was used for each plant. A syringe was discarded immediately if it touched anything other than the nutrient solution.

The HEPA (high efficiency particulate air) filter in the laminar flow hood was replaced at the start of the first trial and was tested and certified. A calibrated pressure gauge was used to monitor the autoclave and ensure that appropriate pressure (at least 103 kPa) was maintained during the entire cycle.

Each improvement in the materials or sterile technique while developing this system increased the length of time that axenic conditions were maintained (Fig. 4). Major improvements included growing plants in a laminar flow hood in Trial 4, enclosing the entire plant in Trial 5, and wearing sterile gloves and covering seedlings with premeasured sterilized sand in Trial 6. In the most successful trial (Trial 6), 85%—or 12 out of 14—plants remained free of microbes for 70 d, after which the trial was terminated due to plant size. The materials and methods as well as results from Trial 6 are reported here.


Figure 4
View larger version (29K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
 
Fig. 4. Effect of time on contamination under four cultural conditions. After each successive trial, changes were made in the next trial to decrease contamination. The most successful was Trial 6, which is described here. Only two out of 15 columns were contaminated at the end of Trial 6.

 
Verification of Sterility
Three different tests were used to verify sterility of the columns: plating leachates on agar, microscopic observation of stained leachates, and a rhizoplane stain. Aliquots of leachate (20 µL) from each plant were pipetted onto plates of 1/10 strength Difco nutrient broth and 1.5% Bacto agar. Dilute nutrient concentrations in the agar are more similar to growth conditions in the rhizosphere than concentrated media. Plates were incubated for at least 3 d at 25°C before visual examination for microbial growth. Repeated sampling of leachate from each plant throughout the study provided the ability to distinguish between a truly contaminated plant and contamination that was introduced after a sample had been collected (a false positive). Identification of false positives occurred when subsequent platings of leachate from the same column were clean.

In addition to plating, a direct total microbial count was used to double-check sterility. The Epifluorescent Microscopic Method (American Public Health Association et al., 1998) was used: 5mL of leachate were stained with acridine orange and filtered through a 0.2-µm nonfluorescent membrane. The membrane was then mounted on a microscope slide and observed at 100x under an ultraviolet light. Microbes could be seen in the leachate of plants that were identified as contaminated on the plates.

A rhizoplane stain using phenolic aniline blue (Rovira et al., 1974) was also performed on root samples at the end of the study. Young root segments and root tips, where microbial symbiosis or infection is most likely to occur (Curl and Truelove, 1986), were excised, stained with phenolic aniline blue solution (Schmidt and Paul, 1982) for 3 min, and mounted on slides.The root segments were then rinsed in sterile filtered water, mounted in water on a microscope slide, and observed under 100x. This confirmed the visual observations in the petri dishes.

Harvest Procedures
Plants were harvested on Day 70 in a laminar flow hood using sterile techniques. The plant growth columns were disconnected from the air flow and removed from the storage rack. After the upper glass column was removed, the plant was slowly pulled from the root-zone column. This removed much of the sand because it adhered to the roots. Sand that fell away from the roots was labeled "bulk sand" and saved in a sterile container for analysis. The roots were then gently shaken to remove additional sand, which was labeled "rhizosphere sand" and stored in a sterile container. A small segment of root was then excised for microscopic observation. The shoot was cut off, rinsed with deionized water, and dried in an 80°C oven. The roots and remaining attached sand were stored in a sterile container at –20°C. Dried shoot tissue was prepared by grinding and HNO3–H2O2 digestion (Mills and Jones, 1996) and analyzed by ICP-OES (inductively coupled plasma–optical emission spectroscopy) for P, K, Ca, Mg, S, Fe, B, Zn, Mn, and Cu at the Utah State University Analytical Laboratories, Logan.

Exudate Analysis: Leachates
Carbon in the leachate of six columns planted with one plant as well as one unplanted control column was analyzed with a total organic C analyzer (Model Phoenix-8000, Tekmar-Dohrmann, Cincinnati, OH), which uses an ultraviolet–persulfate reaction to oxidize organic C to CO2. All samples were frozen at –20°C and analyzed at the end of the study using a single standard curve.

Because of their chelating properties and ubiquitous presence in previous exudate studies, we examined organic acids for a qualitative analysis of exudates. The analytical methods used to determine exudate composition were the same as those used by Kloss et al. (1984), whereby the acids were esterified to increase their volatility, and analyzed as their methyl esters using GC-MS (gas chromatography–mass spectrometry).

To esterify the samples, 1-mL aliquots of each leachate (or extract of roots or sand, see below) were added to 3 mL of methanol and acidified with 0.6 mL of 50% H2SO4 (v/v). The acidic methanol mixture was heated for 1 h at 50°C, then cooled and diluted with an additional 3 mL of H2O. One milliliter of chloroform was added and the sample was vigorously shaken, then incubated about 30 min. The chloroform layer was removed and the components in the chloroform were quantified using GC-MS (Models 6890N/5973, Agilent Technologies, Palo Alto, CA). Chromatography conditions were: 1-µL injection; column flow rate = 0.6 mL min–1; split ratio = 3.6; column DB-624 = 30 m x 0.25 mm x 1.4 µm; temperature program = start at 50°C, increase 5°C min–1 to 200°C and hold for 5 min. Methyl esters of the dicarboxylic acids were quantified using pure compounds (Aldrich Chemical Co., Milwaukee, WI). A concentration range of 0.5 to 10 mg kg–1 showed good linearity for calibration of each organic acid (r2 = 0.997–0.999).

Exudate Analysis: Growth Column
To extract organic acids, sand attached to the roots was separated into approximately 5-g samples. Three milliliters of 0.1 M NaOH were added to each sample. The sample solutions were intermittently mixed for 1 h at room temperature and then separated from the sand matrix by filtration. The extracts were then analyzed using the esterification/GC-MS method described previously for analysis of leachates. A similar extraction was used to determine TOC in the rhizosphere sand using 50 mL 0.1 M NaOH.


    RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
 TOP
 NOTES
 ABSTRACT
 INTRODUCTION
 MATERIALS AND METHODS
 RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
 CONCLUSIONS
 REFERENCES
 
Plant Health
The green, turgid appearance of the plants indicated good plant health throughout the trial. The tops of leaves curled under when they touched the foam plug at the top of the upper column. To improve the system, taller and wider upper columns for shoot growth would allow longer studies, provided that space in the laminar flow hood was not a limiting factor. The size of the root zone was less of a concern since nutrients and water were being replenished regularly and the five-layer sand medium provided ample pore space for O2 to reach the roots. The relatively similar vertical water content (caused by the five layers of sand) facilitated uniform root growth throughout the root-zone container. Inductively coupled plasma–optical emission spectroscopy analysis of shoots showed that nutrients were present in adequate amounts (Table 3) compared with critical ranges (Marschner, 1995). The airflow rate through the upper columns was increased as the plants grew, which minimized condensation inside the columns. This continuous airflow kept relative humidity<80% and replenished CO2 for photosynthesis.


View this table:
[in this window]
[in a new window]
 
Table 3. Average nutrient content of shoots (n = 6) using ICP-OES (inductively coupled plasma optical emission spectroscopy). Nutrients were present in adequate amounts (Marschner, 1995).

 
Average shoot dry mass ranged from 1.08 to 2.31 g. The variability in plant mass was due to differences in time to seedling establishment. Root mass was not determined, but root evaluation in a preliminary trial indicated that the average root mass was 25% of the total plant mass at harvest for all treatments. A root mass of 25% was thus assumed for the calculations in Table 4. Plant dry mass at harvest was highly correlated with cumulative transpiration rate (r2 = 0.96, data not shown), so plant mass throughout the study was back-calculated based on daily transpiration data (Fig. 5).


View this table:
[in this window]
[in a new window]
 
Table 4. Seven ways to express exudation assuming that exudate C accounts for 40% of exudate mass (CH2O).

 

Figure 5
View larger version (25K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
 
Fig. 5. Plant mass during the study estimated from transpiration rate. Each curve represents one plant. Evaporation was subtracted from all plants.

 
Water Availability
Water content was maintained by the layered-sand medium between 40 and 90% of pore volume for each layer (Fig. 2). The water held by the column at container (field) capacity was 49 mL ({theta}v [volumetric water content] = 0.32) based on gravimetric tests. The plant-available water in the columns was about 0.035 L, based on the volumetric water content at which transpiration rates of crested wheatgrass plants started to decline (Fig. 6). Plants were watered to maintain water loss below 0.035 L to minimize water stress.


Figure 6
View larger version (20K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
 
Fig. 6. Transpiration rates of three replicate plants with volumetric water content ({theta}V) decreasing from container capacity ({theta}v [volumetric water content] = 0.32). Transpiration rates decreased when moisture content was lower than about {theta}v = 0.1, so the readily available water was about 35 mL in the 154-cm3 sand columns (22% of column volume).

 
Adsorption and Desorption of Compounds to Ottawa Sand
Oxalic and malic acids are common plant-derived compounds and are in the dissociated form (negatively charged) at pH 8, which was the pH of the leachate from the planted columns. Tests based on electrical conductivity recovery of 0.02 M KCl, and 0.02 M oxalic and malic acids (pH raised to 8) added to the columns indicated that all of the material introduced was recovered within three rinses with deionized water. These concentrations were chosen because they represent amounts of C similar to those leaching from plant roots throughout a preliminary study. The rapid recovery of charged and organic compounds from the system suggests that Ottawa sand does not significantly adsorb charged or organic compounds and that recovery of compounds from the sand should be rapid. Carbon leached from the unplanted column near the end of the study was <10% (w/w) of the planted columns (Fig. 7).


Figure 7
View larger version (21K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
 
Fig. 7. Exudation rates per plant per day during the study. Error bars represent standard errors of the mean.

 
Electrical conductivity of the leachate throughout the study averaged 143 mS m–1 (1.43 µmhos cm–1), compared with 114 mS m–1 (1.14 µmhos cm–1) in the 1/3-strength nutrient solution. The electrical conductivity values for the unplanted column were similar to the planted columns, indicating that residual salt accumulation in the sand was minimal.

Recovery of Compounds from the System
As an alternative to collecting exudates directly in the nutrient solution, transfer of roots from nutrient solution to deionized water for 1 to 24 h to collect root exudates has been used in some short-term solution culture studies (Fan et al., 1997; Ratnayake et al., 1978; Ström et al., 1994). This procedure would reduce salt interference with analyses but may bias results since the amount and composition of root exudates can reflect the nutritional status of the plant. Nutrient deficiencies may change the composition or induce increased amounts of exudates (Kraffczyk et al., 1984; Römheld, 1991; Ratnayake et al., 1978). Wang et al. (2002) have shown that activation of genes associated with P, K, and Fe deficiencies can be induced within 1 h after withholding these nutrients from the plant. Since this response was confined to the root, a rapid response in root exudate composition to nutrient deficiency is also probable. Aulakh et al. (2001) found 0.01 M CaSO4 to be a good leachate collection medium that did not interfere with TOC or HPLC analyses and did not increase TOC or the proportion of sugars exuded, as was observed with deionized water. We recommend an appropriate qualitative analysis that is not affected by salt content of the exudate sample.

Achieving and Maintaining Axenic Conditions
Since the stage when contamination is most likely and plants are most susceptible to damage occurs when seedlings are being planted, rapid transfer of the germinated seed from the agar plate to the moistened sand is necessary. Initial sterility was improved by minimizing the exposure time of the growth columns and germinated seeds to the surrounding air during planting by pre-assembling components before sterilizing. It is not necessary that the entire seedling be covered by sand, just the seed coat and root initial. Additional time spent burying the seedling during planting (i.e., with a spatula) increases exposure time and increases potential for microbial contamination. Extra sand was autoclaved separately to pour on top of seedlings during planting. This eliminated the need to bury the seedling with a spatula and reduced the number of manipulations and length of time the column was exposed to the surrounding air. It was useful to practice the planting techniques under nonsterile conditions before doing the sterile manipulations.

In both of the contaminated plants, roots grew through the glass wool, emerged out of the drain tube, and were briefly exposed when the surrounding vial was changed. Because a rhizoplane stain of roots from within the system was free of microbial growth, it is likely that only the emerging root segment was contaminated.

Although plants were kept in the laminar flow hood and sterile gloves were always worn when watering and replacing vials, direct exposure of the plant to the surrounding air resulted in contamination. This implies that long-term axenic plant culture would be unsuccessful in a nonsterile growth chamber.

Procedures for cleaning the system components probably reduced microbial contamination. The 20% H2O2 treatment used to reduce residual TOC on the sand was powerful enough to kill most microbial cells, and the deionized water washes physically removed microbial cells and spores from all components. All water used for cleaning was filtered, since any debris would interfere with microscopic observations.

Verification of Sterility
The use of three separate methods to confirm sterility provides a high level of confidence in the results, but all methods have limitations. Since acridine orange stains DNA, all living material is stained, including root cells. This might result in false positive identification of contamination. However, contaminating microbes would most likely be attached to surfaces, and the sand and glass wool could have filtered these microbial cells before they reached the leachate. Additionally, this method does not allow time for microbial multiplication so the microscopic observations might miss single cells, compared with agar plates in which growth makes the microbes more visible. The acridine orange method was effective in identifying contaminating microbes in the leachate from the two plants that had roots emerging from the bottom of the column.

The phenolic aniline blue stain of root segments was the most direct means of assessing contamination but only one slide was made for each plant and this slide represented only a small part of the root system. This method could miss contamination if it was confined to one part of the root zone.

Exudate Analysis
Total organic C was monitored in the leachates throughout the trial. Exudate concentrations were converted to micrograms of C per plant per day based on values in milligrams per kilogram provided by the TOC analyzer and the time between waterings (Fig. 7). Leachate TOC was highly correlated with plant size (r2 = 0.93). Carbon leached from the unplanted control ranged from 15 to 60 µg C d–1, or about 10% of the planted systems. The TOC remaining on the sand at the end of the study was, on average, 26% of the leachate TOC (Table 5). The 17% TOC found in the rhizosphere (sand immediately adjacent to the root) is probably an overestimate because small root pieces and root hairs contaminated the sand. The presence of root hairs, small pieces of roots, border cells, and compounds that reacted with the Fe may all contribute to insoluble organic compounds that were detected as residual TOC on the sand.


View this table:
[in this window]
[in a new window]
 
Table 5. Average distribution of rhizosphere C based on TOC (total organic carbon) analysis of leachates and C remaining in the sand.

 
Carbon exudation rates observed here were lower than those reported in the literature (Table 4). Many different units have been used to describe exudate production. Radiolabel studies commonly express exudates as a percentage of the C fixed by the plant (Biondini et al., 1988; Shepherd and Davies, 1993). Other studies expressed exudates per unit mass, e.g., per gram plant or per gram root (Schönwitz and Ziegler, 1982; Lynch and Whipps, 1990). Plant age, size, and stage in the life cycle influence growth rate and could alter root exudation rates.

The lower amounts of exudate in this study compared with the literature may be due to plant age or growth conditions. Plants in other studies were all younger than in this study, and most plants in previous studies were grown hydroponically. Average exudation rates in this study would have been higher if the study had been terminated earlier since exudation rates decreased at the end of the study. This study was continued as long as possible to evaluate exudation on a long-term basis.

Similar to the rates of TOC release, the rates of organic acid release in the exudates also peaked before the end of the study. Fumaric, succinic, oxalic, malonic, and malic acids were quantified (Table 6). Organic acids detected in the rhizosphere sand were minimal.


View this table:
[in this window]
[in a new window]
 
Table 6. Cumulative amounts of organic acids in leachates and rhizosphere sand samples at harvest detected using gas chromatography–mass spectrometry.

 
Detection limits of the dissolved acids were ~0.4 mg L–1 for the leachates using 5-mL samples, and ~0.6 mg kg–1 for the sand using ~1-g samples. The esterification had poor efficiencies for hydroxy-diacids (carboxylic acids with a hydroxyl group) since it was not designed for these compounds. It is possible that hydroxyacids other than those detected were present in the exudates. Organic acids were corrected for recovery efficiencies, which were: oxalic acid 22 ± 3%, n = 10; malonic acid 50 ± 6%, n = 10; fumaric acid 51 ± 6%, n = 10; succinic acid 56 ± 4%, n = 10; and malic acid 15 ± 7%, n = 8.

There were several challenges with the organic acid analysis. Acids were present in low concentrations in the leachate, and sample volumes were too low to be concentrated, for example by lyophilization. The biggest difficulty was in derivatizing the acids to methyl esters for analysis, especially acids like malic acid that contain a hydroxy group in their structure. The presence of the hydroxy group on a neighboring C atom changes the reactivity of the carboxyl group, making the esterfication reaction less likely to go to completion and thus leaving some acid in the sample unreacted. Low concentrations coupled with low derivatization rates may have reduced the number of acids. For example, citric acid is a common acid found in root exudates. Citric acid mobilizes phosphate and chelates Fe and Al in the rhizosphere, but it was not detected in this study. Citric acid is also a hydroxy acid, thus its decreased ability to be esterified and its presence in low concentrations may have contributed to its absence of detection in this study. The absence of citric acid may also be due to adequate Fe supplied to the plants, thus reducing the need to exude Fe-sequestering compounds.

The composition of the other exudates is unknown. Other compounds such as sugars and amino acids may also have properties useful for phytoremediation.

The variability associated with the organic acid analysis (Table 6) is probably due to the poor esterification efficiency. High performance liquid chromatography and ion chromatography have been used for exudate analysis, but it is more difficult to separate the different acids with these methods and they are less sensitive than gas chromatography (Szmigielska et al., 1995). Ion chromatography is typically used for general anion analysis and does not require derivatization of the acids but requires higher concentrations than those in the leachates from this study. A more comprehensive method was used by Fan et al. (1997) with nuclear magnetic resonance and GC-MS for de novo identification of exudate components, which is useful for analyzing unknown compounds. Liquid chromatography–mass spectrometry allows analysis without derivatization and provides structural information for positive identification of unknowns, but LC-MS instruments are very expensive. Depending on exudate concentrations and instrument availability, these methods may provide analyses with less variability.


    CONCLUSIONS
 TOP
 NOTES
 ABSTRACT
 INTRODUCTION
 MATERIALS AND METHODS
 RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
 CONCLUSIONS
 REFERENCES
 
Practicing the sterile techniques described here and performing multiple sterility tests are necessary for a successful axenic plant study. The design of this system is conducive for long-term studies because the setup reduces microbial contamination and provides an environment for healthy plant growth. The inert components and sterile conditions made TOC analysis of root exudates possible. Low concentrations of organic acids in the root exudates required the use of GC-MS, but resulted in poor derivatization and low recovery rates. We recommend ion chromatography analysis with higher organic acid concentrations or LC-MS if available.

Since this system allows the application of treatments and collection of leachates to monitor root exudates, it is suitable for many types of studies, including the effects of inoculation with pure microbial cultures and the effects of biotic and abiotic stresses such as heavy metals, all of which can provide insight into the dynamics of root exudation.


    ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
 
We greatly appreciate the help of Dr. Michael Petersen for the GC-MS analysis, as well as Dr. Melinda Hamilton, Dr. J. Richard Hess, and Dr. Carl Palmer for suggestions on system design.


    NOTES
 TOP
 NOTES
 ABSTRACT
 INTRODUCTION
 MATERIALS AND METHODS
 RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
 CONCLUSIONS
 REFERENCES
 
Work supported by the Idaho National Environmental and Engineering Laboratory, and by the Utah Agricultural Experiment Station, Utah State Univ. Approved as Journal Paper no. 7552.


    REFERENCES
 TOP
 NOTES
 ABSTRACT
 INTRODUCTION
 MATERIALS AND METHODS
 RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
 CONCLUSIONS
 REFERENCES
 




This article has been cited by other articles:


Home page
J. Environ. Qual.Home page
R. Child, C. D. Miller, Y. Liang, R. C. Sims, and A. J. Anderson
Pyrene Mineralization by Mycobacterium sp. Strain KMS in a Barley Rhizosphere
J. Environ. Qual., July 17, 2007; 36(5): 1260 - 1265.
[Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]


Home page
J. Environ. Qual.Home page
A. Henry, W. Doucette, J. Norton, and B. Bugbee
Changes in Crested Wheatgrass Root Exudation Caused by Flood, Drought, and Nutrient Stress
J. Environ. Qual., May 7, 2007; 36(3): 904 - 912.
[Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]


This Article
Right arrow Abstract Freely available
Right arrow Figures Only
Right arrow Full Text (PDF) Free
Right arrow Alert me when this article is cited
Right arrow Alert me if a correction is posted
Services
Right arrow Similar articles in this journal
Right arrow Similar articles in ISI Web of Science
Right arrow Similar articles in PubMed
Right arrow Alert me to new issues of the journal
Right arrow Download to citation manager
Citing Articles
Right arrow Citing Articles via HighWire
Right arrow Citing Articles via ISI Web of Science (3)
Right arrow Citing Articles via Google Scholar
Google Scholar
Right arrow Articles by Henry, A.
Right arrow Articles by Bugbee, B.
Right arrow Search for Related Content
PubMed
Right arrow PubMed Citation
Right arrow Articles by Henry, A.
Right arrow Articles by Bugbee, B.
Agricola
Right arrow Articles by Henry, A.
Right arrow Articles by Bugbee, B.
Related Collections
Right arrow Laboratory Column Studies
Right arrow Lysimeter/Rhizosphere Studies
Right arrow Bioremediation and Biodegradation
Right arrow Experiment Design
Right arrow Plant Nutrition


HOME HELP FEEDBACK SUBSCRIPTIONS ARCHIVE SEARCH